Why elevator pitches don’t work
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/073c7/073c7a47eae6d2f60117f49fd13ccd12332f5336" alt=""
What prompted me to write this article about elevator pitches was reading an article published by Asana. It said:
“A good elevator pitch can be the difference between landing your next big opportunity or falling short of the competition.”
Really? Does this stack up?